Who Is Behaving Most Unreasonably? Look Closely Before You Answer
FAQ
What is the best way to solve this puzzle?
Trace each cut, then consider what the whole plank looks like after all of them.
Is there a single correct answer?
The most defensible answer is that all four are acting unreasonably, though some people argue for one person.
Can I try this at home?
Please don’t saw anything you’re sitting on. Use a sketch instead.
What should I avoid?
Judging people by appearance, or ignoring how the cuts combine.
Conclusion
The puzzle’s lesson is that actions have combined effects. Each person’s saw looks like a small decision, but together they remove every support. Look closely, trace the cuts, and explain your reasoning. Share it with a friend and compare answers. For your site, you could link to an internal article on more visual logic puzzles.